Almost perfect in every way. It is very lightweight but just wore out in 45 degree weather with only a T-shirt and small scarf. I was perfectly warm even though the wind really picked up. The jacket is so light; the pockets are huge - enough for phone, hands, doggie bags, keys - and have a good zipper; the sturdy structure of the fabric gives a really nice appearance; long enough to cover hips in the back; and a really nice color. And I should mention even though a couple of other folks got jackets with scratchy seams that appears to have been corrected. So what would make it perfect? As another commenter noted thumbholes in the sleeve would be great. I'd love one in another (not black or grey) color like green or blue. Would certainly buy it. And as one commenter said the sleeves are long -- a good thing for some of us if not everyone.